Little Gull Cafe

If you are ANYWHERE remotely close to this adorable little gem, GO! Absolutely incredible food with a sweet and attentive staff. Can’t wait to come back again soon! We had the BLT, pancakes, burger, and breakfast sandwich and all were delicious.

High welfare personal chef here I got the breakfast sandwich with an over hard egg, American cheese, the house made sausage and added sauteed greens—to go. Easily one of the best breakfast sandwiches I’ve ever had. First time there. Service is a little slow but understandably as they are very popular and very small. Do not expect to be greeted and seated when arriving as the waitresses are constantly running around serving people and there wasn’t a hostess. Will be back next season!

Went with my mom to start off our mommy-daughter day and we were confused at first from the outside. But as soon as we walked in, we loved it. The staff let us choose our table, they came to our table to get our order without us having to wait for too long, and we got our food pretty quick after ordering; and it was DELICIOUS. We loved every moment of the experience and we can’t wait to make the trip out there just to eat at the Little Gull Cafe again! Also convenient for people traveling by the LIRR as there is a station right across the street.

This spot is too cute. We affectionately call it the “Whistle Stop Cafe” because it reminds us of the cafe from the epic film “Fried Green Tomatoes”. I can’t eat here enough. The only way they could be better is by being open more hours! When the weather is nice we bring our dog to sit outside. Great staff and large portions of food that you can tell is made with love!

This spot is fantastic! Legit some of the best bread (made on site) I've ever had. Grabbed some chocolate pistachio cake to go which was outstanding. Can't wait to return and try the pancakes. Cool atmosphere too, especially all the plants hanging from ceiling. Will def be back.

Went last night for dinner, which is always nice to try and catch because they don't always have dinner service. Everything was so delicious. My husband and I split a farm greens salad, I had the fish sandwich & my husband had the pickle dog. Everything was super flavorful and well made. This fish was fried to perfection and the tartar sauce on the side was soo good! When we went there was live music that was at the perfect noise level. You can hear the tunes loud and clear but can still have a conversation. The pacing of the meal was nice and relaxed. Staff was accommodating and friendly.

One of our favorite spots! Best pancakes and hashbrowns...everything is actually delicious. The space is in an old train station. Cute little restaurant with a few tables indoors and, in warmer weather, there’s a few tables outdoors as well. Fire beer on tap too! Sometimes a short wait to be seated but 100% worth it :)

This might be the best breakfast on Long Island. The sourdough pancakes are fabulous - soft but with a great bite. The sausage is unique and tasty and the bacon had all the great bacon flavor without being too salty. The Little Gull Rolls use on the breakfast sandwich are light and fluffy, but holds everything together. Hash browns are very crispy. Coffee is great. And the house-made biscuits. I'll keep coming back for those alone. They're not as tender as a proper southern biscuit, but the flavor is there. And it's the best I've found on Long Island by a huge margin. The space is tiny, but quaint and cozy. While the service on my first visit was a bit slow, it was perfectly timed on the second. Both visits I arrived at opening, and the 21 indoor seats fill almost immediately. Third visit: I arrived an hour before closing, waited to be seated, and got my food 1:15 later. Fried chicken sandwich is good with bacon, though I bet it would be even better on a biscuit. I would have tried it, but they were out (not too surprising). Lemonade is just sweet enough, and tastes freshly squeezed. I like it sour, so I this was great. Fourth visit I tried the pumpkin pancakes. It tasted strongly of pumpkin puree, with a dense moist texture. They were okay (though certainly high quality) but my least favorite thing I've tried.